Immigration Reform is Needed to Spur Economic Growth, Job Creation, and Innovation

Introduction

Both political parties understand that we need immigration reform to help stimulate the economy, create jobs, and foster innovation. However, because immigration law and policy is such a politicized issue, there has seemed to be little momentum to reform “legal” immigration law and policy.

Of course, battles relating to illegal immigration and border security and the status of so-called “dreamers” — those brought into the United States illegally as children — are receiving the most attention. But we also need to be discussing the impact of legal immigration on our economy and how the “legal” immigration system needs to be reformed in order to grow our economy.

For example, there are numerous studies that show that if we reduce immigration then economic growth and development will decrease, the gross domestic product “GDP” will also fall, and unemployment would also rise. There are a myriad of reasons why economists say immigration accelerates, rather than slows, economic growth. Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody’s Analytics, states that “more immigrants are going to be buying more.”

When you have more people consuming more products, demand increases and production increases, which leads to job creation, and economic growth and development. Therefore, reforming the “legal” immigration system would grow the economy and create jobs.

EB-5 Immigrant Investor Visa

One of the visas that has created the biggest impact on economic growth and job creation is the EB-5 Immigrant Investor Visa Program. Under the EB-5 immigrant investor visa program, foreign nationals who invest in certain U.S. businesses can obtain lawful permanent residency, also known as a green card.

The program requires an investment of $1 million in a new commercial enterprise or $500,000 if directed to “targeted employment areas,” typically rural areas or those with high unemployment. Since 2008, this program alone has exceeded $20 billion dollars in foreign direct investment into the U.S. and has created over 174,000 US jobs.

EB-5 stands for employment based fifth preference category. There are also other employment based visas. Congress currently caps employment based visas at 140,000 annually. This number hasn’t been adjusted since 1990, even though the economy has doubled in size since then.

Moreover, the least available of these visas, is the EB-5 (capped at 10,000). Expanding all employment based visa categories and especially the the EB-5 program would build on the economic success of the program.

Benefits of Foreign Direct Investment in the US

For example, EB-5 capital has contributed to the development of the LA Live Entertainment District, the Barclay’s Center, the Oakland A’s arena, Paramount Condos at Miami Worldcenter, Four Seasons Hotel in New York City, and many more.

The program brought in over $5 billion in 2017 alone. Making more EB-5 visas available would mean increasing foreign direct investment in the US, along with increased job creation – this is a Win-Win situation.

     

Political Uncertainty on Reform

The EB-5 Immigrant Investor Visa Program and other employment based visas hang in the balance under this cloud of political uncertainty on both sides of the aisle.

Congress intended for all employment-based green cards to go to workers and investors and for green cards for their family members not to count against the numerical cap. However, every administration since the early 1990s has counted these family members against the cap — essentially cutting the number of employment-based green cards annually in half.

Alex Nowrasteh, of the Cato Institute, states that as a result, “65 percent of those who earned EB-5 green cards in 2016 were the family members of the investors. At a minimum, the family members of the investors should be exempt from the cap, just like all family members should be exempt from the numerical cap in the employment-based green card categories.”

Conclusion

Therefore, immigration reform is crucial in stimulating the economy. Congress should expand all the employment based visa categories and add a startup visa for entrepreneurs, which will spur economic growth and development, create jobs, and foster innovation.

References:

Anderson, Stuart, National Foundation for American Policy, Immigrants and Billion Dollar Startups, February 2016.

Anderson, Stuart, National Venture Capital Association, American Made 2.0 How Immigrant Entrepreneurs Continue to Contribute to the U.S. Economy.

McDaniel, Paul, Revitalization in the Heartland of America, Welcoming Immigrant Entrepreneurs for Economic Development, 2014.

Furchgott-Roth, Diana, The Economic Benefits of Immigration, 2013.

This article has been provided by the Subhan Law Office, LLC. For additional information, please contact [email protected].

Copyright © 2018 Subhan Law Office, LLC. All rights reserved. Reprinting or digital redistribution to the public is permitted only with the express written permission of Subhan Law Office, LLC. For inquiries please contact us.